Baking with The Energy Detective

Date Saturday, February 7th, 2009 at 6:22 pm Posts By Ryan Brown

I’ve discussed Energy Monitoring in previous posts:

I have now purchased and installed my own TED Model 1001 energy monitor so I thought I’d share my thoughts.

Energy Detective Details

The Energy Detective (TED) is a fairly simple device – a measurement unit installed in my electrical panel transmits real-time power consumption data to a LCD display.  The display unit tracks peak levels and can display power in kilowatts (kW) or dollars as well as the line voltage.  Here’s what came in the box:

IMG_2330

IMG_2337

You’ll notice the USB port on the LCD unit – I paid an extra $40 for the TED Footprints software so I can log and view data on my PC.  More on this in a moment.

Installation was fairly straightforward, as long as you don’t mind mucking around in your electrical panel.  I won’t go into detail – you can read the instructions and muck around at your own risk :) .  If you’d rather avoid the hassle an electrician could easily install this in less than an hour.

Next there are a few setup steps on the Display Unit – you can enter electrical rate details which allows TED to display in dollars (and $/hr).  It works well with the Austin Energy 2 tiered rate model and seasonal rate change. 

Living with The Energy Detective – My Review

I’m not going to say that TED changed my life, but I certainly enjoy having it.  I’m kind of a data addict and TED allows me to measure and track my power consumption.  The first hour or so after I installed it were spent turning on all of our lights and appliances and monitoring the change in kWh.  Kind of nerdy, but an enlightening experience.

For anyone considering the TED, I would highly recommend the Footprints software.  It allows me to connect the TED display to my PC and log the data.  This has been very useful for tracking the performance of our HVAC system as well as monitoring our use-patterns.

All of the above information has helped me to live more efficiently and consider the costs of leaving a light on, or even baking brownies…

Baking with TED

Last weekend I baked a small pan of brownies in our electric oven.  Brownie ingredients are pretty cheap (chocolate, eggs, butter, etc.), but I was curious as to the cost of the ‘embodied energy’ (at least my oven’s contribution).  So I pulled up the TED data for the afternoon, here is a snapshot:

image

Here is a PDF of the full-size chart: TED-Baking.pdf

This graph shows a lot of good data.  The TED takes a measurement every second, so the x-axis shows the time I spent baking.  The blue plot is the power consumption (in kW) – this is what we’re after.  The red plot is the voltage (RMS) of the power lines – interesting mainly to see the power quality from Austin Energy and to see it drop as I draw more current.

First – Wow!  My oven takes some power!  The plot jumps up about 5 kW when the oven started pre-heating.  I checked my owner’s manual and it turns out I have a 5 kW heating element – this supports the measurement data.  It’s also interesting to see how the heating element turns on and off to maintain the 350 degree temperature.  This is basically the same control algorithm used by your average thermostat – simple but effective.

Also notice the two ~ 2 kW spikes around 2:40 pm – this was when I used the microwave to melt the butter/chocolate mix.  Here’s a closer look at this section of the plot (oven pre-heat and microwave):

image

With the TED power measurement for each second, I can calculate the total power consumption for baking the brownies.  This is the area under the blue plot in kilowatt-hours.  To be fair I’ll remove the ~0.6 kW base level as this is due to the lights, computer, fridge, etc. in the house. 

image

So there you have it – Thanks to TED I know that baking brownies required 1.67 kWh of power, which cost me about 12 cents.

Conclusion

You get the idea – The Energy Detective is a neat way to learn more about how you consume electricity, which should help you to be more efficient in your consumption.  I think installing TED is a great idea for builders – costing less than $200 it’s very affordable feature and it can immediately measure/demonstrate the effectiveness of the home and its systems.  Of course TED can eventually pay for itself by helping to reduce wasted energy. 

What do you think?  Is the TED providing worthwhile data or is this too much information?  Share your questions or comments below.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • FriendFeed
  • LinkedIn
  • Posterous
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
Related Posts

15 Responses to “Baking with The Energy Detective”

  1. Matt Risinger Says:
    February 9th, 2009 at 3:03 pm

    Ryan, Super cool post. I love that you figured out it cost $1.62 for those brownies including $1.50 for the boxed mix and 12 cents to bake them! Way cool. How about tracking your TV for a while? -Matt Risinger

  2. Ryan Brown Says:
    February 9th, 2009 at 9:57 pm

    Thanks Matt! I’m not sure I want to know how much electricity/money I spent watching the Aggies struggle last season.

  3. Nana Says:
    February 10th, 2009 at 3:12 pm

    Wow Ryan, now just resist baking brownies 1,667 times and you will have paid for the TED! ;P

  4. Ryan Brown Says:
    February 16th, 2009 at 10:12 pm

    Very funny Nana! I probably have a better reason to avoid baking brownies (a low exercise to brownie-consumption ratio) but it’s never stopped me before. :)

  5. Noah Thanks Says:
    March 3rd, 2009 at 11:54 am

    It’s not under $200.00. In your article you said you paid an additional $40.00 to “unlock” the data port. I think this is ridiculous. I’m looking at competitive solutions where there’s no “up-charge” to access the data monitored by the unit.

    I would pay an additional $40.00 for ethernet–the ability to plug the unit into my lan. I wouldn’t ever consider paying additional to “unlock” a data port that is provided with the device.

  6. Ryan Brown Says:
    March 3rd, 2009 at 12:06 pm

    I agree that charging for the software to access the data is annoying, this is critical for anyone wishing to monitor and log power use. Ethernet would be better – a simple web server on the TED could allow for viewing real time data from anywhere. There is definitely room for improvement here – what solutions are you considering? Note: I think the total is still < $200:
    TED 1001 = $144.95
    TED Footprints software = $44.95
    Total = $189.90 (+ S/H)

  7. merrill Says:
    April 13th, 2009 at 3:25 pm

    What alternative solutions provide either an ethernet port or web monitoring abilities? Thanks

  8. David Boarder Says:
    May 15th, 2009 at 9:38 am

    I installed one just a week
    ago. If you are comfortable with working in your electrical panel the installation is extremely simple. My home has a 400Amp service which means it has 2 x 200 Amp panels. The model 1002 can handle this as it comes with 2 transmitter and it sums the readings from each panel to provide a total. It also shows the value per panel which is also useful. I do have a couple of issues with the system though. First on their site they indicate it should not interfer with X10 devices. I found this not to be true as it seems to randomly turn on all my X10 lights. The second problem I found is that if I try to run the Footprint software on my Laptop the whole TEDS unit stops keeping accurate time. It starts to lose 15 minutes every hour. However it seems to work just fine plugged into my desktop.

  9. Michael Says:
    May 19th, 2009 at 7:50 pm

    I’m thinking about getting one of these. A few questions though.

    How does the software “know” what appliance or light has been turned on?

    For David Boarder: I also use X10. Do you have a SignaLinc™ Plug-in Coupler-Repeater? I had to get one because my house wiring made X10 fail a lot–this cured the problem.

  10. David Boarder Says:
    May 19th, 2009 at 8:30 pm

    The profile of appliances is a weak point in my opinion. The way it knows (or think it knows) what has turned on is that you train it to know how much the current the appliance draws. You do this by typing in the current or put it in “learn” mode and it then turn on the appliance and it measures the increase in current. The problem is that you find often there are loads which are so close it gets confused. It does work okay for large loads like an electric water heater.
    As for the X10 issue the problem is not with the X10 system. Everything works fine and I do have a SignaLinc repeater. The problem is that the TED which is not supposed to be using the X10 protocol (but something similar) is somehow sending something which seems to be interpreted by the X10 switches as “all on” Very irritating to have all the lights turn on randomly.
    According to the TEDs site it “should” not interfer with X10 receivers.

  11. Craig Page Says:
    May 20th, 2009 at 6:56 pm

    I’m a Control 4 dealer in Baton Rouge, LA. Did you know that TED has a certified driver that installs on the Control 4 system and allows the user to view your data on your TV and or other GUI offered by Control 4? If your not familure with our system, it gives you the ability to control your lights, thermostats, AV equipment, ect.You can use the info from your ted to trigger events to automaticly start or stop.FYI(www.control4.com)

  12. Craig Page Says:
    May 20th, 2009 at 7:05 pm

    P.S. Control 4 devices use Zigbee wireless communication.Other words 0 influence from other equipment & no need for phase couplers or repeaters:)

  13. The Boiler Man LLC Says:
    August 17th, 2009 at 10:22 am

    Hey, Can someone today Monday 8-17-09 Email me on did they ship the same day ordered? and How long did it take to get this Ted -1001 there is two prices $144 and $159 appears the Ted 1001 comes with software to monitor all am i correct ? Who has the Best Price___? I am concern about all the power transformers to power and charge Note Books, Laptops and Cell phone charges, Many other ac to dc adapters, Hopefully this will give me a more sensitive reading as i am told my Laptop charger – power cord 120vt 1.6amps to 19volt DC 3.42amps or 65 watts left plugged is costing me $11 to $18 a month at .13202 per KWH so with many i am curious of the real cost ? I am also thinking of getting one of the Kill A Watt EZ KW-P4460 to be more accurate on each connection.. Any Thoughts ? Thanks Rick / The Boiler Man Heating and Plumbing and 1st How to DVDs from Vermont

  14. Claire Says:
    October 7th, 2009 at 8:17 pm

    Are there simpler ways to monitor electical use? Can someone explain simply how a person with basic computer skills would use TED? Do I need the computer hook up? I want to know the cost of running full vs. 1/2 empty dishwasher, full vs. 1/3 empty clothes washer, leaving TVs plugged in, etc.

  15. Ryan Brown Says:
    October 8th, 2009 at 11:30 pm

    Good questions, I’ll try to answer:

    Ethernet/Web monitoring: TED just announced Google Power Meter integration for their new model 5000.

    Claire: I think for single-load monitoring/testing the Kill-a-watt is a good place to start. It doesn’t have computer integration (that I know of) but you can monitor power by simply plugging in your lights, TV, etc.

Leave a Reply